Bug #20593
open`Kernel#format` emits a `too many arguments for format string` warning when called with a single hash and no key is used
Description
Kernel#format
emits a warning when too many arguments are passed.
It does so for postional arguments, which make sense, as it could be indicative of a bug:
$VERBOSE = true
format("%s", 1, 2) # warning: too many arguments for format string
And doesn't for keyword arguments, as it's much less likely to be a bug:
$VERBOSE = true
format("%{a}s", a: 1, unused: 2) # no warning
However it does emit a warning when passing keyword arguments, if none are used:
$VERBOSE = true
format("test", unused: 2) # warning: too many arguments for format string
Which I believe is a bug, as it's common for format
to take a user provided string to allow for safe interpolation, but with no intention to enforce any of the arguments to be interpolated.
So I think that last case shouldn't emit a warning.
Updated by Earlopain (A S) 6 days ago
Huh, interesting. I didn't realise it worked that way. I recently fixed a few of those in rubocop but didn't catch on that it only applies when the string takes no arguments.
This makes sense to me. Fixing these warnings didn't improve the code and is unexpectedly inconsistent.
Updated by byroot (Jean Boussier) 6 days ago
Proposed patch: https://github.com/ruby/ruby/pull/11053
Updated by byroot (Jean Boussier) 5 days ago
- Subject changed from `Kernel#format` emits a `too many arguments for format string` warning when called with keyword arguments and none are used to `Kernel#format` emits a `too many arguments for format string` warning when called with a single hash and no key is used