Bug #19442
Updated by eightbitraptor (Matt V-H) almost 2 years ago
[GitHub PR #7317](https://github.com/ruby/ruby/pull/7313) ~~Ruby Ruby doesn't compile when USE_RINCGC is disabled. It's also not being tested in CI. As @nobu has pointed out in comments on the PR, fixing it is simple.~~ This was fixed in [this commit](https://github.com/ruby/ruby/commit/21543ac86ce0b730c1381588d7dc9eb0e32277c7) simple. I think there are 2 approaches we should remove could take: 1. Remove `USE_RINCGC` entirely and always run with incremental GC enabled, because I don't think this flag is being actively used, and removing it will simplify the code and reduce the cognitive overhead of working with the GC. enabled. We have a precedent for this: `USE_RGENGC=0` was removed [in this commit](https://github.com/ruby/ruby/commit/62c2b8c74e47652fc5bbaf6150f4acd092dfd72b) almost 3 years ago. `USE_RINCGC=0` is in a similar state. It has been broken for almost a year (since [this commit](https://github.com/ruby/ruby/commit/dde164e968e382d50b07ad4559468885cbff33ef)), and [disabled in CI for more than 2 years](https://github.com/ruby/ruby/commit/46d3ea2c2569e2e5a9ee3e7e206f07f0f8b693f5). 2. We could fix `USE_RINCGC`. If we do this we should re-enable the CI task so that we continue to keep it working in the future. I am very much in favour of option 1, because I don't think this flag is being actively used, and removing it will simplify the code and reduce the cognitive overhead of working with the GC. However I am happy to defer to the team here.