Feature #16816


Prematurely terminated Enumerator should stay terminated

Added by headius (Charles Nutter) over 1 year ago. Updated 8 months ago.

Target version:


When iterating over an Enumerator, there are three different possible results of calling next:

  1. The next item is returned and a cursor is advanced
  2. There's no next item and the Enumerator will forever raise StopIteration
  3. There's an error getting the next item which is raised out of next

This third case has some unexpected behavior that I discovered while working on

It seems that when an Enumerator fails prematurely with an exception, any subsequent call to #next will cause it to restart.

This can be seen in a simple script I used to write a ruby/spec in {
  2.times {|i| raise i.to_s }
}.tap {|f|
  p { rescue $!.message }

The output from this is [0, 0]. After the iteration fails, the second next call causes it to restart and it fails again.

Contrast this to the behavior of item 3 above; when an Enumerator finishes iterating without error, it remains "finished" forever and can't be restarted.

I believe the restarting behavior is at best undocumented behavior and at worst incorrect and unspected. Take this example:

e = { |y|
  c = new_database_cursor
  5.times { y.yield c.next_result }

If next_result here raises an error, a subsequent call to next on this enumerator will cause it to restart, re-acquire the cursor, and begin again.

As another example I ask a question: how do you indicate that an Enumerator failed due to an error, and keep it failed so it doesn't restart again?


Also available in: Atom PDF